Because of the way the data on teacher certification exams is kept, the Times could not determine a test score for every teacher. ");act.setLinkBack("http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2015/investigations/pinellas-failure-factories/teachers/");var showShareBarUI_params={containerID: "componentDivpinellas-countys-most-segregated-elementary-schools-also-have-hired-teachers-with-troubled-pasts", shareButtons: [{provider: "twitter", iconImgUp: "http://www.tampabay.com/projects/assets/sharing/twitter_inline.png"}], showCounts: "none", iconsOnly: "true", userAction: act};var params = {userAction:act, enabledProviders: "twitter"};gigya.socialize.showShareBarUI(showShareBarUI_params); They include instructors who have badgered co-workers, committed minor crimes and become physically aggressive with children. Overall, black children in Pinellas County are failing at higher rates than black children in virtually any other school district in Florida. When it came time to take standardized tests in the spring, she tried to remember what she had learned, but she often couldnt summon the correct answers. Teacher turnover is a chronic problem, leaving some children to cycle through a dozen instructors in a single year. In an interview with the Times, Superintendent Mike Grego acknowledged the school districts role in creating problems at the schools. They said fewer teachers quit the schools last year and internal testing suggests students are making academic gains. Far more so than other schools in the county, Campbell Park, Fairmount Park, Lakewood, Maximo and Melrose rely on first-year teachers to fill out their staffs. A certified teacher of elementary school children and non-native English speakers, she said her Lakewood students could barely read. However . None of the schools was ranked lower than a C. Today, all the schools have F ratings. Curtis Fundamental Elementary, which has been A-rated since 2001 and where about 80 percent of students are white, has hired only one rookie teacher in the past five years. Dunedin High School is an above average, public school located in DUNEDIN, FL. In all, James had a dozen different fill-ins between August 2014 and June 2015. They installed new magnet programs to encourage voluntary integration. They missed a combined 30 days of work that year. Then they crisscrossed the state to see how other school districts compared. The chance to do away with busing finally was at hand. Before joining the Times in 2013, Lisa covered D.C. Public Schools for The Washington Examiner. Then as black children started failing at outrageous rates, as overstressed teachers walked off the job, as middle class families fled en masse the board stood by and did nothing. We had almost all new people at these schools. Ranked by the state Department of Education, Melrose is the worst elementary school in Florida. In an interview with the Times in May, Grego recalled the situation he inherited when he started. Pinellas Countys black students havent been struggling in secret. Featured Review: Parent says Carwise Middle School is a wonderful school. This is what its like to go to school in Pinellas Countys black neighborhoods. He was replaced by Julie Janssen, who launched her own programs to stop the test-score freefall at schools in south St. Petersburg. To examine the quality and experience of teachers in Pinellas County schools, the Tampa Bay Times obtained more than a dozen databases from the state Department of Education and the Pinellas County School District. Public opposition steadily built until 2007, when the School Board got out from under federal monitoring. None of the substitutes seemed able to control the classroom, she said. They found teachers in the whiter schools are more experienced, more likely to stay in their jobs and more likely to have clean employment records. District officials said there are early signs of improvement. Confront the real issues head on for the children. Lakewood High School is an above average, public school located in ST PETERSBURG, FL. Lige George sat for the general knowledge exam twice before passing. Mikal Guthrie was banned as a substitute at Lealman Avenue Elementary in February 2000 after teachers complained she used inappropriate language in the classroom and passed the time reading silently rather than teaching lessons, her personnel records show. It was funded by federal money earmarked for poor children. ");act.setLinkBack("http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2015/investigations/pinellas-failure-factories/teachers/");var showShareBarUI_params={containerID: "componentDivthey-offered-few-incentives-to-keep-seasoned-teachers-at-the-schools", shareButtons: [{provider: "twitter", iconImgUp: "http://www.tampabay.com/projects/assets/sharing/twitter_inline.png"}], showCounts: "none", iconsOnly: "true", userAction: act};var params = {userAction:act, enabledProviders: "twitter"};gigya.socialize.showShareBarUI(showShareBarUI_params); They replaced the ones who fled with recent graduates who had never taught before. More than two years later, district officials have done nothing with the list. They offered few incentives to keep seasoned teachers at the schools. Herself a product of Florida public schools, Lisa grew up in Palm Beach County. I dont want them there because theyre making $5,000 extra.. Zariyah said the constant shuffle at Maximo made it hard to learn. Others skipped work to avoid the stress. But just because they dont have 10 or 15 years experience doesnt mean theyre not the highest quality teachers.. Reached by the Times, Shores described long hours and a thankless work environment at the southside school. I can tell you that, sure as Im sitting here.. Tampa Bay has had many close calls since 1921. The five neighborhood schools on the citys south side became almost entirely black. Until the resources match the need, the district will continue to chew up our teachers and spit them out. James Sampson had so many teachers at Melrose Elementary that the 9-year-old couldnt keep them all straight. How district leaders turned five once-average schools into Failure Factories. This article was written while Times reporter Michael LaForgia was participating in the National Health Journalism Fellowship, a program of the University of Southern Californias Annenberg School of Journalism. The kids were horribly behind, Mermelstein, 43, said in an interview with the Times. We thought through it. It has 1,196 students in grades 9-12 with a student-teacher ratio of 20 to 1. Because once people leave those areas, they are not coming back., Even Clayton Wilcox, the then-superintendent and a champion of dropping the integration plan, admitted at the time that he doubted that schools with so many impoverished students could succeed. They say they are not convinced real changes are coming. But that still left Maximo behind more than a dozen schools in the district. Manuel Sykes, pastor of Bethel Community Baptist Church in St. Petersburg. Pinellas County: Pinellas: No: Yes: No: No (727) 943-5508: 269: 20: 13.7: 26.8%: 205 (76.2%) 21 (7.8%) 26 (9.7%) 9 (3.3%) 2 (0.7%) 1 (0.4%) 5 (1.9% . Its only after a few years in Pinellas classrooms that theyre falling behind their peers statewide. Schools in poor, black neighborhoods would get more money . Florida. About 260 elementary school teachers hired by the district in the past five years failed certification exams four or more times. June 29, 2023 - The district outpaced the state in many areas with fifth-grade science scores in the top 10 among the largest districts in the state! In 2014, he expanded a program to add classroom aides, mental health therapists and navigators to connect families with services outside the school district. The teacher got in trouble a second time for leaving students unsupervised. The five worst elementary schools in Pinellas County all among the very worst schools in Florida have seats with their name tags on them. His fourth-graders accused him of constantly hugging and touching some girls and calling others stupid, idiot, retard, and fatty, personnel records show. Some members questioned the $1 million price tag to train teachers in managing student behavior. The bullying took its toll. I believe we understood that when we put that commitment into the plan.. Words by Michael LaForgia. #4 in Pinellas County Schools Rankings #110 in Florida Rankings; East Lake High School is ranked 110th within Florida. If we kept all the things that we promised going, we wouldnt be seeing the results that were seeing, Janssen, who now goes by her maiden name, Mastry, told the Times in June. They werent the only examples. In less than a year, schools on St. Petersburgs north side became whiter, and the neighborhood schools to the south began drawing primarily from the citys blighted avenues and subsidized housing complexes. Times reporters spent a year reviewing tens of thousands of pages of district documents, analyzing millions of computer records and interviewing parents of more than 100 current and former students. Maximo and Melrose had Cs. Top 5 Schools in This City These are some of the top-rated public schools in St. Petersburg based on a variety of measures, including academic performance and equity. Times reporters wrote computer software to link the databases, then compare schools across the county based on teacher turnover, longevity and other factors. Totaling more than 6 million rows, the records included data on where teachers work, their hiring and firing dates, years of experience, state certification exam results and substitute teacher assignments. Elementary Schools. She wanted to focus on her work, but the disruptions that year proved too much for the little girl. At his former school, Woodlawn Elementary, he was disciplined for leering at a fellow employee from the doorway of her classroom, winking and smiling if she made eye contact and for making comments about the kinds of jeans he thought would look good on her. 12. As recently as 2006, no school was more than 48 percent black. 10. In Palm Beach County, at Belle Glade Elementary in one of Floridas poorest places black children are passing reading at three times the rate as at Melrose. That, they said, will help ensure a higher level of scrutiny in selecting the best candidates for their schools.. She was forced to resign from Gibbs High by administrators who told her she wasnt suited to work in a majority-black school. Cayton Bodden wakes up afraid to go to school. 122 of 206 Pinellas County Most Diverse Public Middle Schools in Pinellas County 26 of 50 See How Other Schools & Districts Rank The U.S. Education Department opened a civil rights investigation. [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] No other large school district in Florida has problems on the scale of Pinellas, but all of them are doing more to raise their black childrens passing rate. A year earlier, Kailels P.E. That amounted to more than 10 percent of the teachers typically on staff. Then they broke promises of more money and resources. He resigned the following year, 2010, citing personal reasons. They settled in south St. Petersburg because it was the only place she could afford to live, she said. It used to be that Melrose had no trouble keeping good teachers in the classroom. The school crisis in Pinellas Countyon Florida's west coast on Tampa Bayis a familiar story of court-ordered integration followed in short order by devastatingly thorough resegregation . Times Staff. Why Pinellas County is the worst place in Florida to be black and go to public school. I was like pulling my hair out, saying, You cant do this! he said. Fifty years of research has shown that such decisions set districts back, said Gary Orfield, co-director of the Civil Rights Project at UCLA and a leading expert on school segregation. Tel: (727) 547-7536. www.pcsb . We were willing to make the sacrifice, Ruth said. If youre only there one or two days, how can a child learn?");act.setLinkBack("http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2015/investigations/pinellas-failure-factories/teachers/");var showShareBarUI_params={containerID: "componentDivevery-child-doesnt-learn-the-same-if-youre-only-there-one-or-two-days-how-can-a-child-learn", shareButtons: [{provider: "twitter", iconImgUp: "http://www.tampabay.com/projects/assets/sharing/twitter_inline.png"}], showCounts: "none", iconsOnly: "true", userAction: act};var params = {userAction:act, enabledProviders: "twitter"};gigya.socialize.showShareBarUI(showShareBarUI_params); For decades, the school district bused children around Pinellas County to keep schools racially integrated. In survey comments gathered by the district in 2008, one elementary school teacher wrote: The majority of our faculty and staff are happy to be at Campbell Park Elementary. How district leaders turned five once-average schools into Failure Factories. I have to pray over this baby every day that he leaves my house to come in here, do you understand?. Numbers are based on matching 60 percent of teachers across the county. First in a series|Aug. 14, 2015 On the day of the School Board decision, Dec. 18, 2007, teachers in the southside schools were roughly as experienced as teachers in the northside schools. States with the best (and worst) schools; List of worst schools in Miami-Dade; . So do the rates of poverty, reliance on food stamps and unemployment. Some in the pool had lost their jobs because their schools closed or student enrollment dropped. SEMINOLE, Fla. (WFLA) First responders in Pinellas County came together to prepare for the worstan active shooting situation. Unless I made enough money to send him to a private school or stay at home and teach him, this is the only option I have.. Best High Schools in Florida - FL School Rankings; Pinellas County is the worst place in Florida to be black and go to . Load all 155 schools. There were 1,664 regular elementary schools tested in Florida in 2014. Pinellas County Sheriff's Office holds mass shooting exercise, testing response to worst-case scenario . We work well together and complement strengths and weaknesses., By 2014, their feedback had turned bleak: I cant believe that the county has allowed the destruction of a good south county school. Campbell Park is No. What do they do? Then, in 1971, they voted to desegregate countywide. In Pinellas, where 80 percent of black families live near the poverty line, that resulted in a racial bias. On a report card in the fall, his teacher wrote that he couldnt compare groups of objects or write numbers. As he struggled through the second grade, he could barely read or do math. Many parents interviewed by the Times felt trapped in neighborhood schools or forced to take extraordinary steps to enroll their children elsewhere. But others were forced out because of poor performance. Its not unusual to see dysfunction at schools wracked by poverty. They slapped him and kicked him. Ninety-five percent of black students tested at the schools are failing reading or math, making the black neighborhoods in southern Pinellas County the most concentrated site of academic failure in all of Florida. Teachers in the mostly black schools are less experienced, more likely to quit and more likely to have been flagged for incompetence or misconduct. Help would have come sooner if district leaders had followed through on promises. And we have no way out of it.. Every inch and pound of research will tell you to place experienced and well-trained teachers at struggling schools. And we have no way out of it.");act.setLinkBack("http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2015/investigations/pinellas-failure-factories/5-schools-segregation/");var showShareBarUI_params={containerID: "componentDivits-really-like-a-parent-being-put-in-a-maze-she-said-and-we-have-no-way-out-of-it", shareButtons: [{provider: "twitter", iconImgUp: "http://www.tampabay.com/projects/assets/sharing/twitter_inline.png"}], showCounts: "none", iconsOnly: "true", userAction: act};var params = {userAction:act, enabledProviders: "twitter"};gigya.socialize.showShareBarUI(showShareBarUI_params); There are places in Florida where deep generational poverty, runaway crime and rampant drug use make educating children an extremely difficult task. As one gauge of teacher quality, Times reporters reviewed a database of more than 2.5 million state teacher certification test results and studied how Pinellas instructors fared. She said she called the school, sent faxes to the district headquarters, even hounded the principal and the area superintendent until they agreed to meet with her. The states three main licensing tests measure basic reading and math ability as well as knowledge of teaching methods, among other things. The district analyzed state test scores and identified about 600 teachers whose students showed the biggest improvement year over year. Find out more about GreatSchools ratings . Using state and district. It called for a neighborhood schools system that kept students close to home. We will burn out, leave the school and leave the profession.. Though her living arrangement is tenuous, Washington said shes glad to be away from south St. Petersburg schools. Even before he won the district's top job, Hendrick. The team runs teacher training, tracks discipline data and oversees remedial programs in reading and algebra. Myrna Starling was about 25 years into a teaching career at Maximo Elementary when the board resegregated the district. Sign up for emails about this investigation. In 2009, the year after resegregation, at least 50 elementary schools got more money per student than Campbell Park. Once, in March, as he was lining up in class, a boy slapped the back of his head and kicked him hard in the calf. Then came Ms. Flynt, Ms. Schick, Mr. Graveley and Ms. Smith. It was like getting your soldiers better equipment, better pay. And a little more segregated. In a 2013 turnaround plan filed with the state, the district pledged to recruit its most effective teachers to work at struggling schools. Pinellas Countys most segregated elementary schools also have hired teachers with troubled pasts. They found the southside elementary schools were 50 percent more likely than all other Pinellas elementary schools to employ a teacher who had failed state exams at least once. Through a widely collaborative effort and with keen attention to details that support victims' needs, Community Action Stops Abuse Pinellas (CASA) opened the state's first Family Justice Center. Part Two Aug. 21, 2015 Violence is a part of daily life in Pinellas County's most segregated. In Pinellas County, such teachers are disproportionately clustered in the five most segregated elementary schools. In 2014, more than half of the teachers in these schools asked for a transfer out.var act = new gigya.socialize.UserAction();act.setTitle("In 2014, more than half of the teachers in these schools asked for a transfer out. Principals at the southside schools had to hire about 550 teachers in the past five years. They could have carefully constructed magnet schools and special programs to attract more white children to schools in black neighborhoods. Between 2008 and 2012, the southside schools became the countys poorest and most challenging places to work. Data reporter Nathaniel Lash, computer-assisted reporting specialist Connie Humburg, data director Adam Playford and news researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. More than 90,000 pupils are being taught at under-performing prim A lot of people were cussing, standing on desks, Zariyah said last year. But during that time, district leaders offered their teachers no extra money or resources. At least three of them simply walked off the job without giving notice, opting to risk action against their state teaching certificate rather than stay a moment longer. First they abandoned integration, leaving the schools overwhelmingly poor and black. Accreditation Certificate . They offered few incentives to keep seasoned teachers at the schools.var act = new gigya.socialize.UserAction();act.setTitle("They offered few incentives to keep seasoned teachers at the schools. Grego boosted funding for the schools in 2014, aggressively targeting them for the first time since they were resegregated. 46 of 599 Best Public High Schools in Florida 82 of 702 Best Public High School Teachers in Florida 96 of 674 Best High Schools for STEM in Florida 122 of 497 Most Diverse Public High Schools in Florida 212 of 965 Best High Schools for Athletes in Florida 324 of 1,204 Tampa Area Compare Lakewood High School to Other Schools When people have complained about black students poor grades over the years, district leaders and teachers have blamed parents, and the students themselves. Elementary, one of the best magnet schools in the area, Cayton cant get into the program. Every year, they turn out a staggering number of children who dont know the basics. Most of his other teachers were a different story. Barely 4-foot-8 in his sneakers and lugging a green camouflage backpack, Cayton spends his school days wary of what might happen next. We told them every year that we needed more help, said Mary Anna Matthews, who taught at Campbell Park for 23 years before opting to retire in 2010. It was a systematic poisoning.var act = new gigya.socialize.UserAction();act.setTitle("It was a systematic poisoning. For years, that thinking held sway, helped along by a county teachers union that often resisted the notion of paying certain instructors more than others. A majority live in a roughly 12-square-mile area south of Central Avenue in St. Petersburg. And three to four years down the road, if this isnt working, it is too late to go back to it then. 8600 Boca Ciega Drive, St. Petersburg, FL 33706. None of these districts has problems on the scale of Pinellas where five of the states 15 worst elementary schools are clustered in the countys black neighborhoods. When his mother knocks at his bedroom door, the 10-year-old hides under the covers. Find a School School Rankings. Teachers would be overwhelmed. Any improvements are coming late for James Sampson. On average, the south St. Petersburg schools hired about four times as many chronically failing teachers in the past five years as the districts other elementary schools, a Times analysis showed. #13 Best Public Middle Schools in Pinellas County.Joseph L. Carwise Middle School. At least 60 children are ahead of him on the wait list. Parents are leaving their cars to break up brawls. But a Times analysis of school operating expenses shows the vote didnt trigger a flood of new resources to the south St. Petersburg schools. When you go to neighborhood schools, whites and Asians get schools that function well and blacks and Latinos get schools that are impoverished and fail. No, no, no, he groans softly. Why Pinellas County is the worst place in Florida to be black and go to public school. Times Staff. In May, it finally became too much. Though the efforts were working black students were posting steady gains on standardized tests many parents bridled at the tools of integration. We will close this gap, Grego told the Times. Its so volatile that Moe Thurton wont let his 10-year-old son JLen walk to school. It was a terrible snowball.. That ended the following year, when School Board members voted to halt integration efforts and return to neighborhood schools. Neither Dyer nor George could be reached for comment. In spite of past setbacks, Grego told the Times the district is back on track. This article was written while Times reporter Michael LaForgia was participating in the National Health Journalism Fellowship, a program of the University of Southern Californias Annenberg School of Journalism. The result was constant instability that gave way to tantrums, flipped desks and disruptions, making it all but impossible for James and his classmates to learn. Good teachers at the schools sometimes felt frustrated by their colleagues. The last time . ");act.setLinkBack("http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2015/investigations/pinellas-failure-factories/teachers/");var showShareBarUI_params={containerID: "componentDivkailels-pe-teacher-was-disciplined-for-threatening-to-punch-a-second-grader-in-the-face-for-sneezing", shareButtons: [{provider: "twitter", iconImgUp: "http://www.tampabay.com/projects/assets/sharing/twitter_inline.png"}], showCounts: "none", iconsOnly: "true", userAction: act};var params = {userAction:act, enabledProviders: "twitter"};gigya.socialize.showShareBarUI(showShareBarUI_params); His third-grade teacher was cut from the school at the end of the year for poor job performance. They should have been reading books with paragraphs. Many who fail once or twice go on to have productive teaching careers. and last updated 7:34 PM, Jan 31, 2022 PINELLAS COUNTY, Fla. Recently released numbers from the CDC showed a startling increase in the number of opioid overdoses across the country. Pinellas proposed sweeping fixes for the five schools, including a pay bump of up to $25,000 for teachers. In just two years, Grego cut turnover nearly in half. Pinellas County Schools, FL,6-8,6 Niche users give it an average review of 3.8 stars. We have and keep the very best teachers. More than. With teacher union support, the deal remained in force until two years ago. By NATHANIEL LASH Times Staff Writer Aug. 12, 2015. Resegregating the schools would concentrate the countys poorest, most challenging students into a handful of south St. Petersburg schools. They were 23 percent more likely to fail math than black children in Hillsborough. Teachers describe how conditions got more and more difficult. Maximo is No. Student-Teacher Ratio 15:1 Student-Teacher Ratio. The district offered special training programs at hard-to-staff schools from time to time, but they never lasted for long. They had so many teachers, it added to the problem.. Every child doesnt learn the same. In multiple editorials in 2007, the Tampa Bay Times, formerly the St. Petersburg Times, urged the school district to abandon integration efforts in favor of "close to home" schools. They complained about the inconvenience and the high cost of busing and special programs. We only talk about it in black schools, she added, but we resegregated white schools as well.. Kicked him and called him rathead and snaggletooth.. Palm Beach County trains principals and district administrators to be mindful of ways schools might unintentionally discriminate against black children. Children here are no more likely to live with an unmarried mother or father. Today, a Tampa Bay Times investigation has found, black children in the countys most segregated schools get worse teachers than children anywhere else in the county.

Maco Management Company Inc, Articles W