119:43, 142, 151, 160). Biblical counseling is practical and effective. He is married to Kelly and has five children, praise the Lord, one of whom is with the Lord even now. In his new book, Dr. Ab Abercrombie draws a clear contrast between the temporal provision of humanism and the transformational authority of the Bible. The Proverbs in particular represent his attempt at mapping out the quasi-causal laws of sow and reap that regulate human phenomena.10Coe and Hall,Psychology in the Spirit, 145. She is your life equates instruction or education with life.27William David Reyburn and Euan McG. The second mistake may well mean that, in actual counseling scenarios, Transformational Psychologists may not implement the Scriptures as much as they should (and the case studies that Todd Hall shares in chapter 14 seem to bear this out). In other words, the Lord transforms us (and our counselees) by his Spirit, through his Word. That is, humans were made by Gods wisdom for wise and well living. Thats not something that takes place in the United States. And we live in a country that historically has welcomed freedom, welcomed the practice of religion, welcomed worship of God, but even now pastors are a little fearful about that. The Transformational Psychologist is potentially in danger of calling human knowledge Gods wisdom. Why is it crucial for churches to consult local legal counsel in a cultural environment that is changing quickly? If we want individuals to grow through counseling, and if we want counselees to become wise, we must necessarily employ the Scriptures in dependence upon the Spirit. One variety that has more recently garnered attention is Transformational Psychology (TP). Why Biblical Counseling? His point is that what we do as counselors, were engaged in discipleship practice. This study helps explore professional counselors' understanding of the integration of Christianity into professional counseling. Ed Wilde: Its absolutely my pleasure to be here. Before the mountains had been shaped, before the hills, I was brought forth. And what do we do in those places? Accessed 2014-04-12. We want to acknowledge very clearly that God has given the state legitimate authority and its actually for the flourishing of the church. Get wisdom; get insight; do not forget, and do not turn away from thewords of my mouth. Coe and Hall end their thought-provoking book with a humble invitation: to join them in seeking to develop a spiritually transformative psychology. Proverbs nowhere teaches us that wisdom can be found outside Gods revelation, nor does it encourage us to seek wisdom that way. . Thats certainly true. Thoughtful biblical counselors have done the sameyet without claiming that they were studying Lady Wisdom when they were observing and reflecting. You have taught me a tremendous amounteven things that I was passionate about, but areas where I could refine languageand so Im grateful now to introduce you to our listening audience. The notion that God embedded wisdom in the creation is based on the Egyptian concept of maat, . . John H. Coe Date of Award January 1991 Degree Type Paper Series Evangelical Theological Society papers ; ETS-0130 Comments William David Reyburn and Euan McG. If his contentions regarding inspiration fail, the remainder of his argument founders. The Constitution certainly gives us that right. On the other hand, you had the flag cases involving the Jehovahs Witnesses. John H. Coe, Why Biblical Counseling Is Unbiblical, 1991. The failure to seek God is more a problem with common sense that preternatural rebellion. Coe and HallsPsychology in the Spiritis their proposal for this new approach, and it sketches some of the major contours for doing transformational psychology. The following is their description of TP: Our transformational model is not primarily about how to take the fruits of science and integrate them with Christianity, but to develop a holistic approach to doing psychology and science that is inherently Christian, grounded in the transformed psychologist studying Gods world in God.1John H. Coe and Todd W. Hall,Psychology in the Spirit: Contours of a Transformational Psychology(Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2010), 134. There are certain minimal educational and ethical standards, which I need to adhere to so that when strangers come to me, we know what is going to be part and parcel of this relationship and what they can expect. Through wisdom, God created the world. The United States Supreme Court said you can be a Mormon, you can believe this, but you cant engage in the practice of polygamy. I first found out about TP when I read Dr. John Coes ETS paper: Why Biblical Counseling Is Unbiblical. As I consider myself a biblical counselor, I was struck by his assessment and decided to learn more. There is a legitimate authority there, and it does entails certain elements of the way we interact with other people that may come into conflict with religion. Over two years ago, a childhood sexual abuse survivor who went through the counseling system at Bob Jones University wrote a response to it and a plea to the college to change their counseling system. A url for this article is unavailable due to the manner in which it is embedded in the page. Waltke writes that the book of Proverbs is the intermediary of Gods wisdom.21Ibid., 80. First, Ill summarize the TP model. I think youve helped to give the nuances that explain the wisdom thats behind that. They say Christian teaching about homosexuality causes people to feel bad about themselves. Ed Wilde: Well, the legitimate authority of the government is, as Abraham Kuyper would put it, its to be able to keep human beings alive so that the church has a place to flourish. I have to go to college, I have to go to law school, I have to take the bar exam, I have to have continuing legal education. There are many models of Christian counseling that vie for the consideration of the church. Notice, in the Hebrew parallelism, how Lady Wisdom is there, linked explicitly to King Davids wise teaching. Fourth, Coe ignores the greater context of the book which assumes inspiration for the whole. Hall then proceeds to give a counseling example of Fred and Bonnie (a couple experiencing marital problems), illustrating how the concepts of Human Attachment and Relationality enable him to deeply understand and effectively care for them. As this critique comes from a respected and careful theologian, it is worth exploring in more detail. If we are to think about religion in terms of a particular doctrinal statement, the federal government is neutral on those sorts of things. Of course, other sources of knowledge can help us grow as counselorswe affirm that gladly. The thing that theyre nervous about, that hinders them from jumping into the world of biblical counseling, is the area of law, being afraid in many ways of lawsuits and that sort of thing. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Perhaps a brief footnote is appropriate concerning the nature of inspiration in Proverbs. And academic developments in a variety of disciplines will always be of interest to those who practice biblical counselingalthough the biblical approach to how that knowledge is viewed and used would be different from the TP model. Posted by memoirandremains in Biblical Counseling, Discipleship, Biblical Counseling, Discipleship, Inspiration, John Coe, Proverbs, Why Biblical Counseling is Unbiblical[1]. When we say that we have freedom of religion, we need to realize that necessarily is built into that some kind of conflict with our neighbors. Those are questions that are answered by judges in the context of litigation. The heart of the methodology of their transformational psychology is described in chapter 7, which is titled: An Old Testament Model for a Transformational Science and Psychology. This chapter contains their foundational thesis. Coe argues that the Old Testament sage shows us how human observations can lead to a discovery of the dynamic law-like structures of nature (including human psychological dynamics). The Foundation decries "futile attempts to mix God's Word with unregenerate suppositions and theories." 2 Qty: 1 Sin causes mens evils[6]. Sid S. Buzzell, Proverbs, inThe Bible Knowledge Commentary: An Exposition of the Scriptures, ed. In his new book, Dr. Ab Abercrombie draws a clear contrast between the temporal provision of humanism and the transformational authority of the Bible. Lady Wisdom is embraced as Solomons words are obeyed. We have a very robust doctrine in Christianity that suffering is oftentimes a good thing, that the goal of God in this world is not to make human beings happyat least not in this world. Ed Wilde Sep 28, 2020 Dale Johnson: Today on the podcast, I am excited that we can introduce to you Ed Wilde. The ordinance thats happening in West Lafayette is distinct because it now targets non-licensed providers, which includes us as biblical counselors. Lets consider another key text that Coe cites in this passage. A little sleep, a little slumber, a little folding of the hands to rest, and poverty will come upon you like a robber, and want like an armed man. Wisdom was to be pursued (three times Solomon said get; Prov. As an attorney, I hang out my shingle. He's taught both counseling courses and courses in law there. This means, Coe argues, that the sage studies creation to better know Lady Wisdom. The first is Proverbs 3:1920. The problem with that is that what constitutes freedom of religion in practice can be a little bit more difficult. The sage is a keen observer of his surroundings, as we should be today. And when I go home, my house isnt going to be attacked. By inference, the message is that the Transformational Psychologist, through studying creation, has a greater wisdom than does the biblical counselor because his scientific studies have yielded additional valuable information regarding human behavioral, interpersonal, and intrapsychic phenomena. At that time the Mormon Church required polygamy or permitted polygamy as part of its doctrine. Nevertheless, the sage does act as our biblical model. The message of Proverbs is that Lady Wisdom is received through embracing the inspired words of the book, and embracing the Lord whose Spirit wrote the book. An easy example I had is a friend of mine who attends church here with me at Grace Community Church, by the age of 30 he was married and he had a few children. What then is biblical counseling? James M. Hamilton Jr.,Gods Glory in Salvation through Judgment(Wheaton: Crossway, 2010), 290; quoted in Dan Phillips,Gods Wisdom in Proverbs(Woodlands, TX: Kress Biblical Resources, 2011), 3. However, Coes argument logically proceeds in the other direction: If the writer of the wisdom literature in the Bible was inspired, then his observations and conclusions were not inspired. We have made a careful assessment of TPs exegetical underpinnings and found them to be flawed. As we talk today, pastors have all sorts of questions. . Kitchen,Proverbs: A Mentor Commentary, Mentor Commentaries (Fearn, Ross-shire, Great Britain: Mentor, 2006), 86. See figure 7.4 on this page for a helpful visual summary of the argument. So, why biblical counseling? Does Proverbs teach that wisdom is found in creation? This cosmic ordering structure provides the objective data that makes nature comprehensible.12Ibid., 138. Fry,A Handbook on Proverbs, UBS Handbook Series (New York: United Bible Societies, 2000), 105106. To paraphrase a line from Augustine in his Confessions, he says youre looking for a happy life in the land of death. Ed has been a lawyer in the state of California since 1989. As has been 7 John Street, "Why Biblical Counseling and Not Psychology?" in Counseling: How to Counsel Biblically (Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson, 2005), 32. We are biblical Christians where we try to operate under what God has given to us. Lady Wisdom (Cosmic Wisdom is a term Coe employs) does not represent the causal laws that govern nonhuman natural phenomena; the OT sage does not affirm a moral science. I read this book with much interest, trying to understand what was distinctive about their approach. They saw illustrations and confirmations, rather than discovering authoritative new moral truths in what they observed. The first time it came up, the court found that not saluting the flag was properly reprimanded and you didnt have a religious freedom to not salute the flag. But the primary directive for us who seek to help alleviate the soul troubles of others must be to relationally share the wisdom of God, as it is revealed in the Word of God. As Von Rad wrote, This [world] order [was] simply there and could, in that the last resort, speak for itself. Quoted in Bruce Waltke, Proverbs 115 (Grand Rapids: Wm. Lady Wisdom is, instead, a poetic figure who represents the wisdom of God and is obtained by internalizing the many truths of Proverbs. God gave us His word, the Bible, so that we can use it for life application to obtain true joy and peace. Biblical counseling is not as biblical as it needs to be if it does not happen in a context of compassion for the struggling soul. Dale Johnson: Thats a critical distinction. If a person is a Christian/Biblical counselor they understand the word of God is described as truth (Ps. Biblical counseling is God and Bible dependent. Ed Wilde is an ACBC certified counselor, lawyer, and professor at the Masters University. Bruce K. Waltke,The Book of Proverbs: Chapters 1-15(Cambridge: Eerdmans, 2004), 82. omitted). In fact, such passages as Job 28 (which highlights the hiddenness of wisdom) seem to indicate the opposite. The reader is trained and encouraged to think and respond biblically in all matters of . For more about this, seeThe Proverbs and the Art of Persuasion,by George M. Schwab, Sr.,The Journal of Biblical Counseling14:1 (1995). At heart, Coe creates a sin which sounds more like Laotzu[5] than Jeremiah: Consequently, all wisdom and skill for living well is grounded in and corresponds to the. . I think one of the things that comes up right there is, Yeah, but were gonna run into difficulties anyway. Well, if were going to run into difficulties, then it better be for Jesus sake. The only solution to biblical sin is the death of Christ[7]. Are biblical counselors unbiblical? This brings me back to the original question asked in the opening section: Are biblical counselors unbiblical? Has Coe made his case? If this sounds familiar to you, then you might consider some reasons why you might need Biblical Counseling. The text of Proverbs never actually makes the claim that facts about values can be gleaned from facts regarding creation. Its become much more complicated now. In other words, God gave us the Proverbs, so that we might become wise. 2:1-11; 4:1-19; 19:27). Wisdom is beautiful, majestic, and attractivesomething God utilized in creation and so something that we ought to seek. John Coes article, Why Biblical Counseling is Unbiblical attacks the sufficiency of Scripture as the source for addressing the human condition. Proverbs 4:13 makes this same point: Keep hold of instruction; do not let go; guard her, for she is your life. Notice again howinstructionis subsequently referred to by the feminine pronounher. He has reduced sin to a mere fault, a mistake in perception. Ed has been a lawyer in the state of California since 1989. Christian counseling, also known as "biblical" or "Christ-centered" counseling, focuses on the Christian principles of life. There is a way of life which exists within the world, which a man can discern. However, I think youre shaping that well to help us to understand that cant just be a free-for-all in public spaces. Coe tries to defend the inspiration of the text by contending that he does not deny it (16). Advances in knowledge can be helpful and enthusiastically welcomed, but a thoughtful biblical counselor would not equate those academic advances with Gods wisdom. Im thinking of 1 Peter 2 and we need to maintain a good witness. A clear and specific verse explaining or illustrating a non-propositional source of wisdom cannot be located. . A decisive issue in this discussion is identifying Lady Wisdom, because she implores us to listen to her. You and I have talked a number of times before about a couple of the great hindrances to biblical counseling that I see consistently among pastors. 3:19-20 and 8:22-31), Waltke provides clarity regarding the nature of wisdom in Proverbs: To be sure, biblical texts outside Proverbs speak of Gods revelation of himself as Creator and/or Judge through his creation but Proverbs does not identify this revelation as thesourceof its wisdom. Their clarifications illustrate that there may be a third option. John A. .Coe and Hall,Psychology in the Spirit, 140. Coe does not fully explain this point, but it seems to entail two elements: (1) the writing refers to an observation; (2) and the writer does not say that he was specifically inspired to make this particular conclusion based upon his observation[3]. How will you solve your problems and change what's wrong? See figure 7.4 on this page for a helpful visual summary of the argument. This is an excellent review and well-worth reading. The Bible is fully sufficient, say critics like the Biblical Counseling Foundation. Biblical counselors, pastors, and all Christians would do well to keenly observe the world we inhabit. The world is deeply encoded with wisdom which anyone can ferret out by means of science just like the observation in Proverbs 24:30, At heart, Coe creates a sin which sounds more like Laotzu, Sin is rebellion against God. Why Biblical Counseling? Identifying Lady Wisdom and Defining the Nature of Wisdom in Proverbs. But the crucial exegetical question for Coe to consider is if this parable is giving us a methodology in science of values. (10-11). The conflict will come up when we begin to think about the other entailments of religion. Coes primary argument is that since the sage can make an uninspired observation which is values-laden and authoritative for human behavior, so can anyone. Ive really enjoyed getting to know Ed these last several months. How does Coe prove that point that divine inspiration was not in play in the observation? He appears to see Proverbs as an early example (or precursor) of psychological literature. To fail to discern and live by the Coes Cosmic Wisdom brings injury and harm to some aspect of human functioning and thus but only in parentheses is sin. However, it is worth emphasizing that, even though biblical counselors rely on the Scriptures in counseling, the biblical counseling approach is not at all opposed to scientific investigation. Coe ignores the noetic effects of sin upon the ability to observe, forgetting that men suppress the truth in unrighteousness. 1 (Wheaton, IL: Victor Books, 1985), 913. And because biblical counselors do not seek this extra-biblical wisdom, but rather exhibit what Coe calls an over-reliance on Scripture, they are unbiblical, and, presumably, their counseling is unwise. He says that he does not discount the role of the Holy Spirit and Christ but they become invisible in his actual thinking. Therefore, he endeavors to help individuals who are struggling with various issues in life. Coe argues as follows: Perhaps a brief footnote is appropriate concerning the nature of inspiration in Proverbs. Rom. 2:6). The primary feature of the poem in 8:22-31 on the role of wisdom in creation is its strong emphasis on the cosmic range and authority of wisdomthe poem does certainly not identify wisdom as existing within the creation (italics mine).24 Waltke,Proverbs,81.

Ellis Parking Lansing, San Diego Union-tribune Perkins, Sdk Millbridge Gardens, Articles W