When the judge eventually requested that a university administrator restore order, Associate Dean for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Tirien Steinbach stood up and delivered a prepared speech accusing the judge of harming students by his presence. Fla.), and Dabney Friedrich (D.D.C.). March 13 (Reuters) - Stanford University officials have apologized to a federal judge after law students disrupted his campus appearance last week, while a new video of the event showed the. ), Roy Altman (S.D. spoke at Stanford Law School, at the invitation of the Stanford Federalist Society. Ian Millhiser is a . My intention wasnt to confront Judge Duncan or the protesters but to give voice to the students so that they could stop shouting and engage in respectful dialogue, Steinbach wrote. FIREs award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed. OLSAT Practice Test: Level B (Grade 1, for school purchase) $2.25. Because he took these actionsin my opinion, strategic missteps on his part, even if you think they were understandable or even justifiedthe Stanford situation is less black-and-white than Yale or Hastings, and Dean Martinez is in a stickier predicament. (also via the Free Beacon), the members of the NLG board declared their firm support and admiration for every single person involved in planning or enacting the protest, which represented Stanford Law School at its best: as a place of care for vulnerable people, and a place to challenge oppression and bigotry in all their forms, including on the federal bench., On Sunday, the board of Stanfords chapter of the progressive American Constitution Society (ACS) issued a similar letter (via, ). Duncan has called for Steinbach to be fired; she should be. But at Stanford, Judge Duncan did lash out at the protesters, calling them idiots and acting in a rude and dismissive manner toward them. Federal court to decide whether Pennsylvania rule is an unconstitutional speech code for attorneys or a valid ban on harassment and discrimination. On Monday, Dean Martinez sent a letter about the controversy to Stanford alumni. They know they can make the dean shake, quiver with fear at the thought of being the next dean to be canceled. [UPDATE (4:29 p.m.): I just added Scott Greenfield, whose post I somehow missed. FIRE routinelydefendsthe free expression rights of both invited speakers to speak and student protestors to protest a speaker. Unlike the disruption of Duncans speech last Thursday, there is no evidence Mondays protest of Dean Martinez was disruptive. Cyclists ride by Hoover Tower on the Stanford University campus on March 12, 2019, in Stanford, California. ), (discussing the Duncan visit against the backdrop of, , a transgender-rights case now before the Supreme Court via the emergency/shadow docket): [W]hat does [the Duncan controversy] have to do with the, case? The Stanford Criminal Justice Center is led by Faculty Co-Directors Professors David Sklansky, and Robert Weisberg, and Executive Director Debbie Mukamal. Thanks so the Federalist Society for inviting me, he said during what appeared to be the conclusion of the event. [C]onsistent with anti-racist teachings, [adherents of DEIdeology] seek to use their newly-acquired power to elevate preferred messages and to deplatform harmful speech., : Stanford should punish the students who protested and the administrators who did nothing. In the email, Dean Martinez just shook, using the words shes supposed to use without actually doing anything. Shop tests. Freedom of speech is a bedrock principle for the law school, the university, and a democratic society, and we can and must do better to ensure that it continues even in polarized times.. Addressed to President Tessier-Lavigne and Dean Martinez, the letter expressed frustration with the Stanford administration's response, which has fueled a dishonest narrative being circulated by Judge Duncan and right-wing media.. FIRE is excited to announce that designer, philanthropist, and free speech advocate Sandy Leong has joined our board of directors. I recognized nearly all protestors as 1Ls. Stanford Law School snowflakes, upset over a federal judge speaking at an event hosted by the school's Federalist Society, had their heckling endorsed by administrators as one associate dean. , posted by Eugene Volokh, is similar in substance to her apology to Judge Duncan. In the email, Dean Martinez just shook, using the words shes supposed to use without actually doing anything. Debbie Mukamal In their letter, President Tessier-Lavigne and Dean Martinez told Judge Duncan that what happened was inconsistent with our policies on free speech, and we are very sorry about the experience you had while visiting our campus. They explained that [w]e are very clear with our students that, given our commitment to free expression, if there are speakers they disagree with, they are welcome to exercise their right to protest but not to disrupt the proceedings. Without naming namesbut clearly referring to Tirien Steinbach, Stanford Laws associate dean for diversity, equity & inclusionthey added that staff members who should have enforced university policies failed to do so, and instead intervened in inappropriate ways that are not aligned with the universitys commitment to free speech., In a statement to Ed Whelan, who broke the news of the apology (as well as the original event), Judge Duncan expressed appreciation for the apology, which he accepted. Lets dive in; theres a lot to cover. A few pink slips, on the other hand, might encourage those who remain to behave., Rod Dreher: It was a revolt of the elites, a pogrom against free speech and civil discourse carried out by some of the nations most privileged. $32.73. ), and James Boasberg (D.D.C.). Share. Last Thursday, March 9, a disruptive protest broke out when Judge Kyle Duncan (5th Cir.) Learn with FIRE provides learners with the opportunity to take courses on a wide range of topics, including free speech and due process, designed by our expert staff. I hope its only the beginning.. March 10 - A federal appeals court judge appointed by former Republican President Donald Trump on Friday said Stanford Law School in California owed him an apology after dozens of student. In the letter sent to Duncanon Saturday, Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne and Stanford Law School Dean Jenny Martinez said: We write to apologize for the disruption of your recent speech at Stanford Law School. : As just reported by Aaron Sibarium of the, , Hundreds of Stanford student activists on Monday lined the hallways to protest the law schools dean, Jenny Martinez, for apologizing to Fifth Circuit appellate judge Kyle Duncan, whom the activists shouted down last week. Presented by FIRE and College Pulse, the 2022 College Free Speech Rankings is the largest survey of campus free expression ever performed. ACTEOS Company Profile | ROUBAIX, HAUTS DE FRANCE, France | Competitors, Financials & Contacts - Dun & Bradstreet One other thought: Dean Merinos email suggests Dean Steinbach isnt going anywhere, at least not anytime soon. Addressed to President Tessier-Lavigne and Dean Martinez, the letter expressed frustration with the Stanford administration's response, which has fueled a dishonest narrative being circulated by Judge Duncan and right-wing media.. The elite students of Stanford Law must come to learn that free expression is the most powerful tool for social change ever devised one they could quite capably use to their advantage. 2022 Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression The law school did not immediately respond to an emailed request seeking comment from Steinbach. relies on its two bridges. B.P.J., a transgender-rights case now before the Supreme Court via the emergency/shadow docket): [W]hat does [the Duncan controversy] have to do with the B.P.J. Duncan wrote an opinion piece for the Wall Street Journal last week in which he defended his comments to the student protesters, including calling them appalling idiots, bullies, and hypocrites. He said sometimes anger is the appropriate response to vicious behavior., To contact the reporter on this story: Madison Alder in Washington at malder@bloombergindustry.com, To contact the editors responsible for this story: Seth Stern at sstern@bloomberglaw.com; John Crawley at jcrawley@bloomberglaw.com. Judge Ho is controversial, but hes no Kristen Waggoner, and Judge Branch is far less controversial than both. How will they be received? In case YLS students are getting jealous of all the attention their SLS peers are getting, the Yalies have a chance to take back the limelight. Protestors chased down Riley Gaines after her campus speech. He has argued against same-sex marriage and as a judge refused to use a transgender litigants chosen pronouns. What I learned quickly was in order to successfully manage the unit, action had consequences. FIREs 2022 College Free Speech Rankings are based on the voices of more than 44,000 currently enrolled students at 208 colleges and are designed to help parents and prospective students choose the right school. Im cautiously encouraged that Stanford has promised to implement some form of training for students on the virtues of civil discourse, Duncan said in an appearance at Notre Dame. It was a scene from Dostoevskys political novel, played out in one of Americas most exclusive training schools for its legal ruling class. On Saturday, Stanfords president, Marc Tessier-Lavigne, and the dean of Stanford Law School, Jenny Martinez, sent a joint letter of apology to Judge Duncan. Thanks for readingOriginal Jurisdiction, and thanks to my paid subscribers for making this publication possible. Cruz said the Texas board should take particular care for students graduating from Stanford law school in 2023, 2024 and 2025. ], : The debacle at Stanford Law School is the logical conclusion of DEIdeology. If you still have answer documents purchased before this change, call 800.845.5731 about placing a Stanford scoring-only order, or email testing@bjupress.com.Because write-in booklets are now one part, we cannot offer scoring for two-part booklets for grades 3 and below. ), Stanford Mandates Free Speech Training After Protest of US Judge, Judge Kyle Duncan Stands By Behavior at Stanford Speech, Judges Want Disruptive Law Students Flagged to Employers, Stanford Apologizes to US Circuit Judge for Disrupted Speech (1), Circuit judge welcomes Stanford handling of controversy, Students disrupted Duncan appearance with insults. Its a hecklers veto and its censorship. Recommended. ], , and thanks to my paid subscribers for making this publication possible. Your care for SLS is evident in your messages, and in all that you do to advance and steward our school. My takeaway: Dean Martinez got an earful from alumni about the protest, and Im guessing a lot of the comments were negative. and Lisa Branch (11th Cir. The letter, posted by Eugene Volokh, is similar in substance to her apology to Judge Duncan. The letter said the students right to protest did not include disrupting an event and acknowledged Steinbachs mishandling of the situation. Judges Friedrich, Higginson, and Boasberg are Supreme Court. Texans deserve only the finest advocates as their counsel, and those that engage in screaming and name-calling to make their case, are far from the finest, he said. Early in my career I was a counselor on an adolescent psych unit. predicts, but even that is not a sure thing. He successfully feasted on the crowds disdain, but can you really make the case that youre getting canceled when youre the one launching into calling students things like appalling idiot while they ask questions you refuse to answer?, Mark Joseph Stern: Duncan got the attention he so obviously wanted, drawing instant support from GOP senators and Fox News. OLSAT Practice Test Directions: Level A (Grade K5, for school purchase) $10.25. Students at Stanford Law School disrupted a student-organized event featuring a federal appellate judge. Its clear that Stanfords promises to enforce their non-disruption policies wont be enough to ensure a thriving culture for discussion and debate on campus. If you are a student or a faculty member facing investigation or punishment for your speech, submit your case to FIRE today. Charging interest on student loan debt is actually a good thing. But they have no fear. Also on Saturday, the SLS dean of students sent an email to Stanford FedSoc leaders encouraging them to reach out for support to administratorsincluding Tirien Steinbach, associate dean for diversity, equity & inclusion. ], Rory Little: When repeatedly voiced complaints are ignored and individual rights are perceived as being trampled by the Establishment, principled civil disobedience of generally accepted rules and regulations may be appropriate. Furor grows over unsafe giant X sign atop Twitter building, Marin teens dreams of college soccer dashed by ghastly surfing accident, Taylor Swift in Santa Clara: What to know about Day 2 of Eras Tour stop, Photos: Taylor Swifts Eras Tour in Santa Clara, Elon Musk installed a giant X on Twitter HQ. If the students feared consequences, perhaps they wouldnt have acted. A Stanford Law student who witnessed the ugly protest against a Trump-appointed judge this month says the video doesn't capture how truly dark a moment it was. Representatives for Duncan were not immediately available to return a call to his chamber in Louisiana on Saturday. Heres where they are, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). 01:29 Hundreds of black-clad, masked students hijacked a class by the head of Stanford Law School in protest at her apologizing to the Trump-appointed federal judge who copped abuse from. Counter-speech cant happen if the speaker is censored. Judge Kyle Duncan was speaking to Stanford's chapter of the conservative Federalist Society when about 100 students barged in to protest. 6. 559 Nathan Abbott Way,Room 383 But its a long way from saying that to claiming his whole intent all along was merely to rile up students. Frustration emerges among GOP spending cardinals as conservatives push Fetterman recaps six months in Congress: Fixation on a lot of dumb s, RFK Jr. and Ramaswamy coming up fast in the outside lanes. Steinbach was placed on leave by the law school in March after Kyle Duncan, a . Reach Chase DiFeliciantonio: chase.difeliciantonio@sfchronicle.com; Twitter: @ChaseDiFelice. July 20, 2023. (OSA), Dean Heather Gerken wisely removed Yale FedSoc from OSA oversight and provided FedSoc with a different official, outside of OSA, to serve as their liaison with the YLS administration. . But that wont happen if they keep begging administrators to protect free speech rights only for them. And I dont necessarily mean loud vulgarity and shouting people down. Tirien Steinbach, Stanford Law School's associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion, resigned Thursday, months after her confrontation with Trump-appointed Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan went . Say what you will about Stanford Law students, but they definitely arent lazy!]. There were a few 2Ls or 3Ls there, but not more than a handful. It isnt enough for Stanfords president to rebuke unnamed staff members for failing to enforce the free speech policy. Tirien Steinbach will be leaving her role as associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion "to pursue another opportunity," Dean Jenny Martinez said . The school is reviewing what transpired and will work to ensure protocols are in place so that disruptions of this nature do not occur again, and is committed to the conduct of events on terms that are consistent with the disruption policy and the principles of free speech and critical inquiry they support, Dean Jenny Martinez said. [C]onsistent with anti-racist teachings, [adherents of DEIdeology] seek to use their newly-acquired power to elevate preferred messages and to deplatform harmful speech., GianCarlo Canaparo: Stanford should punish the students who protested and the administrators who did nothing. He was not especially kind to the law students who were baiting and berating him with crude and crass messages about his sex life. She faces a predicament similar to what Dean Heather Gerken faced at Yale Law last year: shes getting attacked by conservatives for being insufficiently protective of free speech (and insufficiently aggressive in punishing protesters), and shes getting attacked by progressives for being insufficiently protective of vulnerable members of the law school community. Project ReMADE is the pro bono entrepreneurship boot camp the Stanford Criminal Justice Center founded and helps run for formerly incarcerated entrepreneurs. Students at Stanford Law School staged a protest against Dean Jenny Martinez on Monday after she apologized for the disruption of an event featuring federal appellate court Judge Kyle Duncan last . Cruz in a letter to Texas officials said there is a fundamental question over whether the students who protested the appearance by Kyle Duncan, a circuit judge for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, are fit to practice law in Texas. Stanfords own policy, as well as Californias Leonard Law, provides Stanford students First Amendment-like free speech rights. But when Duncan attempted to speak, he was shouted down and heckled by student protestors. Tirien Steinbach, the law school's associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion, made national news when she was recorded on . per adult (price varies by group size) 30-Minutes Private Guided Tour of Lille by Convertible 2CV. My guess is that they wont be protested. FIRE calls on the city of Arab to fix its unconstitutional sign regulations. I'd guess about 70 people, at maximum, were in attendanceequal to or less than the number that showed up for the March 9th protest. of (almost) the entire event with Judge Duncan. FIRE routinely defends the free expression rights of both invited speakers to speak and student protestors to protest a speaker. . Merino also suggested that FedSoc leaders consider pausing their student organization social media accounts until this news cycle winds down, since issues tend to escalate and trolls are looking for a fight on Twitter and similar platforms. ), Stephen Higginson (5th Cir. The embattled dean arrived to the classroom where she teaches constitutional law to find a whiteboard covered inch to inch in fliers attacking Duncan and defending those who disrupted him, according to photos of the room and multiple eyewitness accounts. Click through to Sibariums story to check out the photos; this clearly took some SLS students a lot of work. See other industries within the Manufacturing sector: Aerospace Product and Parts Manufacturing , Agriculture, Construction, and Mining Machinery Manufacturing , Alumina and Aluminum Production and Processing , Animal Food Manufacturing , Animal Slaughtering and Processing , Apparel Knitting Mills , Architectural and Structural Metals Manufacturing , Audio and Video Equipment Manufacturing . Fifth Circuit Judge James Ho and Eleventh Circuit Judge Elizabeth Branch wrote in the National Review that law schools should punish students who participate in disruptive tactics and said theyre failing to teach students how to become good citizens.. The #1 rule of Yale Law gunners: you dont bite the hand that feeds you. In this way, students benefit from academic thought leaders across disciplines, not to mention the intellectual life of the campus found in the myriad of conferences and events held each year and in countless other . Check out our library of resources to get started on your First Amendment journey! Taylor Swift defies curfew at Levis Stadium again during second Bay DA wont file charges now against pair accused in S.F. If youre faculty member at a public college or university, call the Faculty Legal Defense Fund 24-hour hotline at 254-500-FLDF (3533). That would be no more than 60 people. And I think that Dean Martinez is in an even trickier position than Dean Gerken or Dean David Faigman (who had to deal with the protest of Ilya Shapiro at UC Hastings). I recognized nearly all protestors as 1Ls. But they have no fear. Scoring is now included with write-in student booklets (grade K5-3) and answer documents (grades 4-12). On Sunday, the board of Stanfords chapter of the progressive American Constitution Society (ACS) issued a similar letter (via KC Johnson and Nicholas Wallace). Federal judges refuse to hire Stanford Law graduates after 'woke' protest. The message sent by the administration should be that we are indifferent about your point of view but it is unacceptable to disrupt a sanctioned event. Thanks! 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. , and you can email me at davidlat@substack.com. You can email me at davidlat@substack.com with questions or comments, and you can share this post or subscribe using the buttons below, comprehensive coverage of the controversy, major problems with the Office of Student Affairs. Stanford Law School has apologized to a Trump-appointed federal appeals court judge after he appeared at an event there and was met with vocal resistance when he tried to deliver remarks in. Duncan, a member of the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, revisited the controversy on Friday and praised Stanford Law Dean Jenny Martinez handling of the matter. Neither Kristen Waggoner of the ultra-conservative Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), who was protested at Yale, or Ilya Shapiro, who was protested at Hastings, fought back against their protesters, which made it difficult to defend the protesters actions. At the commission of the Berkeley City Council, Stanford Law School 3Ls Jena Neuscheler and Akiva Freidlin, authored a major report on the use of electronic control weapons (aka tasers) by police departments. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) urged the Texas state bar to carefully consider the fitness of certain Stanford University law school graduates after a protest over a conservative judges speaking engagement on the campus. When ordering Stanford 10 test support materials, please consult our Stanford 10 page to learn about recent changes to Stanford scoring costs and timing. Tomorrow, March 15, Judges James Ho (5th Cir.) 4. 510 Walnut St. | Suite 1250 He also articulated the hope that a similar apology is tendered to the persons in the Stanford law school community most harmed by the mob action: the members of the Federalist Society who graciously invited me to campus.. Lets say the quiet part out loud. Stanfords student newspaper, The Stanford Daily, reported that audience members protested Duncans appearance before and during his lecture. The free-speech fallout at Stanford Law School continues after last Thursday's headline-making, administrator-endorsed shoutdown of a federal judge by students who said his views were too "harmful" to be aired on campus.. He was not especially kind to the law students who were baiting and berating him with crude and crass messages about his sex life. from. Hundreds of black-clad, masked students hijacked a class by the head of Stanford Law School in protest at her apologizing to the Trump-appointed federal judge who copped abuse from the students. Interesting tidbit from that interview: only two Stanford Law professors have reached out to Rosenberger to express support, the chapters advisor (Professor Michael McConnell) and Professor Joseph Bankman (most well-known right now as the father of FTX co-founder Sam Bankman-Fried, but before that, one of the most popular members of the SLS faculty). But the first paragraph is worth noting: I want to thank those of you who have reached out to me and others at SLS to share your reactions to the event on March 9, 2023. ;-), In addition, also on Monday night, Stanford FedSoc President Tim Rosenberger appeared on Tucker Carlson Tonight (via, ). The apology letter finished by stating: We are taking steps to ensure that something like this does not happen again. Second, and shrewdly on YLSs part, Judges Ho and Branch are part of a larger panel of eight judges participating in this event of the. From Olive Henrietta Rabe (1929) to Kristen Waggoner (2023), a history of women arguing for free speech in the highest court in the land. It was a scene from Dostoevskys political novel Demons played out in one of Americas most exclusive training schools for its legal ruling class. 120 rue de Tourcoing, 59100 Roubaix France +33 3 20 26 04 04 Website Menu. To put it bluntly, Mark Joseph Stern cant possibly know that unless hes a mind reader on the side., Charlie Sykes: While some critics on the left have focused on Duncans petulance, thats not really the key issue here, is it? Because he took these actionsin my opinion, strategic missteps on his part, even if you think they were understandable or even justifiedthe Stanford situation is less black-and-white than Yale or Hastings, and Dean Martinez is in a stickier predicament. There were a few 2Ls or 3Ls there, but not more than a handful. Several student groups issued statements in response expressing their anger at the apology and defending the actions of those who disrupted Duncans speech as merely the exercise of the students own First Amendment right to protest. Tomorrow, March 15, Judges James Ho (5th Cir.) Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. But given the support she enjoys from progressive SLS students (see item #3 below), firing her would cause a huge uproar. At the presentation, Dean Steinbach shook with passionate fury. spoke at Stanford Law School, at the invitation of the Stanford Federalist Society. stanford law dean faces student revolt after apologizing to trump-appointed judge The incident is the latest in a string of high-profile protests at law schools. I would guess that less than a third of the class was represented. Martinez didnt elaborate why but added that all staff would receive training on the schools policy allowing protest but not disruption of events. There are nearly 600 students in our law school. In addition, this source said they did not see any cheering or crying after Dean Martinez left the building. Circuit Judge Kyle Duncan after the appointee of former President Donald J. Trump was heckled by a group of tantrum-throwing. A student protest that interrupted a controversial speaker at Stanford University last week led its president and law dean to criticize campus . If youre a college journalist facing censorship or a media law question, call the Student Press Freedom Initiative 24-hour hotline at 717-734-SPFI (7734). I think the most that might happen to Dean Steinbach would be quiet reassignment in a few months, which is what. If anyone has photos or videos of the Monday protest, I would welcome them; I was obviously not present, so Im only as accurate as my sources and whatever supporting evidence they provide to me.]5. And it is a stark warning about the potentially totalitarian future of the US. (Dreher also interviewed Judge Duncan, which ended with the judge asking, What if, in ten or twenty years time, this kind of behavior is the norm in the courtroom, the law firm, the boardroom? And I dont necessarily mean loud vulgarity and shouting people down. Stuart Kyle Duncan, a judge with the Fifth U.S. Im a little surprised to find myself referring to Yale Law School as a role model on these issues, but after the Yale Federalist Society had. Federal judges refuse to hire Stanford Law graduates after 'woke' protest. Duncan had harsh words for the Stanford protesters on Friday, saying they were there to heckle and to shame.. The paper reported that opponents protesting Duncans appearance put up fliers throughout the campus arguing that Duncan has pushed for laws that have harmed women, immigrants and LGBTQ individuals. A new report from the Stanford Criminal Justice Center At Arms Length: Improving the Criminal Investigation of Police Shootings - recommends ways to improve the criminal investigation and prosecution of police shootings. has 3 surprising new public spaces. Martinez disclosed that Steinbach was on leave in the same Wednesday memo to students announcing the free speech training. Time running out to file for $725M Facebook settlement: How to claim your Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. As has already been communicated to our community, what happened was inconsistent with our policies on free speech, and we are very sorry about the experience you had while visiting our campus., The letter said students were welcome to protest campus speakers they did not agree with, but not disrupt proceedings whether by heckling or other forms of interruption., It also said that staff members who should have enforced university policies failed to do so, and instead intervened in inappropriate ways that are not aligned with the universitys commitment to free speech.. per adult (price varies by group size) 1 Hour Private Lille Tour by Convertible 2CV with a Local Products Tasting. Judges Friedrich, Higginson, and Boasberg are Supreme Court feeder judges, so expect the YLS students to be on their best behavior. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) urged the Texas state bar to carefully consider the fitness of certain Stanford University law school graduates after a protest over a conservative judge's speaking. First, Yale Law School seems to be, , reflected in the successful Return of the Queen (of Darkness): in January, Kristen Waggoner of the archconservative Alliance Defending Freedom spoke at YLS, and her appearance. And it is a stark warning about the potentially totalitarian future of the US. (Dreher also interviewed Judge Duncan, which ended with the judge asking, What if, in ten or twenty years time, this kind of behavior is the norm in the courtroom, the law firm, the boardroom? The fact that this behavior currently has no consequences is why it will continue to re-occur. 3. And the more swiftly and firmly the consequences were delivered the more peaceful and productive the program was for all involved.

Hud Phone Number In Jacksonville Fl For Rent, Duplex For Sale Germantown, Md, Articles S